Notting Hill Carnival: Is Inclusivity Costing Us Its True Spirit?

Notting Hill Carnival. We see it, we smell it, we hear it and we absolutely love it! This vibrant explosion of culture and colour has been lighting up London's streets since 1966, when the Windrush generation brought their Caribbean influence to the city. What started as a small, local celebration has grown into an iconic event, drawing millions of people from all over the world. With its beautiful floats, live performances and multiple sound systems, Carnival is something special. And let’s not forget the food (the most important part) a mouth watering array of cuisines from every corner of the Caribbean islands.

In the 90s, West London witnessed hip-hop legends like Jay Z, Lil’ Kim and Busta Rhymes gracing the NHC stage. Fast forward to more recent years and the likes of Stormzy, Wiley, Craig David, Giggs, Major Lazer, Mr Eazi and Stefflon Don have kept the great vibes going. It’s no wonder Notting Hill Carnival is celebrated as the largest street event in Europe!

While Carnival has become a symbol of modern London—characteristically diverse and inclusive—it remains deeply rooted in Caribbean culture. The influence of the Windrush generation is still evident in every beat of the drum, every sway of the hips and every bite of deliciousness. But as the years pass, I can’t help but reflect on whether this rich history is at risk of being overshadowed or even forgotten in the mix of festivities.

I admit, this isn't something I often ponder on but it’s worth considering: should Notting Hill Carnival be something that’s purely ‘London’—a melting pot of all cultures? Or should it remain, at its core, a celebration of Caribbean heritage? It’s fantastic that people from all walks of life come together to enjoy and appreciate the culture on display. But sometimes, I wonder if the essence of Carnival is being diluted in the name of inclusivity.

Take, for instance, the ongoing debates on social media, especially on platforms like X (formerly Twitter). Every year without fail, there’s a discussion—sometimes heated—about the music being played. Some argue that the sound of Carnival should be reserved for reggae, calypso, soca, and other distinctly Caribbean genres, not for afrobeats, house, or R&B. While this may seem exclusionary to some, there’s a valid point here. Why mix in elements that, while enjoyable, don’t quite fit the original theme? It’s like bringing a carrot to a cabbage patch contest and insisting it be included. Sure, the carrot is delicious and adds variety, but perhaps this isn’t its moment to shine.

Living in London, a city that thrives on multiculturalism and diversity, I understand the desire to be inclusive. But there’s a fine line between inclusion and dilution. If we try to incorporate too much, do we risk losing the message and meaning behind the celebration?

Notting Hill Carnival is more than just a big street party. It’s a living, breathing tribute to the resilience and creativity of the Caribbean community in London. It’s a reminder of the struggles and triumphs of the Windrush generation and a celebration of the vibrant culture they brought with them. As we continue to enjoy this incredible event, let’s not forget its origins. Let’s make sure that the history and heritage behind Notting Hill Carnival remain at the heart of the festivities so that future generations can understand and appreciate its significance.

So yes, dance to the music, feast on the food, and marvel at the parade—but let’s also honour the history that makes Notting Hill Carnival such a unique and important event. After all, it’s not just about having a good time—it’s about remembering why we’re all here in the first place.